A Good Idea Gone Bad. Can we still justify patent monopolies?

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter


Intellectual property is a surprisingly strange beast. Whilst, society as a whole seems to have become somewhat accustomed (or as some critics might argue, inured) to the concept that the products of intellectual effort are protected by property rights, the true (and highly problematic) character of intellectual property itself, the normative questions which surround its existence, and its societal impact sometimes appear unappreciated. Students who first encounter the subject understandably focus on not confusing a patent with a copyright, a copyright with a trade mark, or a trade mark with a design right. They then grapple with subject matter of protection, validity requirements, duration periods, and infringement exemptions for a seemingly endless spectrum of disparate rights. However, this effort can lead to a misapprehension that the world of intellectual property is (save for some minutiae) relatively settled and without substantial normative problems. That is very far from the truth and it is the aim of this work to highlight some of the key problems with the control of the products of intellectual effort and why radical lawyers may wish to take issue with the current position. The focus of this piece is on the control of inventions by way of patents. It will describe why the propertisation of ideas is a significant restriction on freedom which requires substantial philosophical justification, and the extent to which that justification may be undermined by the behaviour of patent right holders. The piece will, in particular, examine the phenomena of strategic patenting, patent thickets, pharmaceutical patent evergreening, and patent trolls, and the impact of patents on the global South.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationGreat Debates in  Commercial & Corporate Law
EditorsAndrew Johnston, Lorraine Talbot
PublisherRed Globe Press (Macmillan International Higher Education)
Number of pages83
ISBN (Print)978-1-352-00931-6
Publication statusPublished - 1 Mar 2020

Publication series

NameMacmillan Great Debates in Law

Cite this