Radiologists can detect the ‘gist’ of breast cancer before any overt signs of cancer appear

Patrick Brennan; Ziba Gandomkar; Ernest Ekpo; Kriscia Tapia; Phuong Trieu; Sarah Lewis; Jeremy Wolfe; Karla Evans

doi:DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-26100-5

Radiologists can detect the ‘gist’ of breast cancer before any overt signs of cancer appear

Patrick Brennan, Ziba Gandomkar, Ernest Ekpo, Kriscia Tapia, Phuong Trieu, Sarah Lewis, Jeremy Wolfe, Karla Evans

Psychology

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

Abstract

Radiologists can detect abnormality in mammograms at above-chance levels after a momentary glimpse of an image. The study investigated this instantaneous perception of an abnormality, known as a “gist” response, when 23 radiologists viewed prior mammograms of women that were reported as normal, but later diagnosed with breast cancer at subsequent screening. Five categories of cases were included: current cancer-containing mammograms, current mammograms of the normal breast contralateral to the cancer, prior mammograms of normal cases, prior mammograms with visible cancer signs in a breast from women who were initially reported as normal, but later diagnosed with breast cancer at subsequent screening in the same breast, and prior mammograms without any visible cancer signs from women labelled as initially normal but subsequently diagnosed with cancer. Our findings suggest that readers can distinguish patients who were diagnosed with cancer, from individuals without breast cancer (normal category), at above-chance levels based on a half-second glimpse of the mammogram even before any lesion becomes visible on the mammogram. Although 20 of the 23 radiologists demonstrated this ability, radiologists’ abilities for perceiving the gist of the abnormal varied between the readers and appeared to be linked to expertise. These results could have implications for identifying women of higher than average risk of a future malignancy event, thus impacting upon tailored screening strategies.

Original language	English
Article number	8717
Number of pages	12
Journal	Scientific Reports
Volume	8
Issue number	8717
DOIs	https://doi.org/DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-26100-5
Publication status	Published - 7 Jun 2018

Bibliographical note

Access to Document

DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-26100-5

s41598-018-26100-5
© The Author(s) 2018
Final published version, 1.35 MBLicence: CC BY

Cite this

@article{226153228177453c8487dd7a612f657f,

title = "Radiologists can detect the {\textquoteleft}gist{\textquoteright} of breast cancer before any overt signs of cancer appear",

abstract = "Radiologists can detect abnormality in mammograms at above-chance levels after a momentary glimpse of an image. The study investigated this instantaneous perception of an abnormality, known as a “gist” response, when 23 radiologists viewed prior mammograms of women that were reported as normal, but later diagnosed with breast cancer at subsequent screening. Five categories of cases were included: current cancer-containing mammograms, current mammograms of the normal breast contralateral to the cancer, prior mammograms of normal cases, prior mammograms with visible cancer signs in a breast from women who were initially reported as normal, but later diagnosed with breast cancer at subsequent screening in the same breast, and prior mammograms without any visible cancer signs from women labelled as initially normal but subsequently diagnosed with cancer. Our findings suggest that readers can distinguish patients who were diagnosed with cancer, from individuals without breast cancer (normal category), at above-chance levels based on a half-second glimpse of the mammogram even before any lesion becomes visible on the mammogram. Although 20 of the 23 radiologists demonstrated this ability, radiologists{\textquoteright} abilities for perceiving the gist of the abnormal varied between the readers and appeared to be linked to expertise. These results could have implications for identifying women of higher than average risk of a future malignancy event, thus impacting upon tailored screening strategies.",

author = "Patrick Brennan and Ziba Gandomkar and Ernest Ekpo and Kriscia Tapia and Phuong Trieu and Sarah Lewis and Jeremy Wolfe and Karla Evans",

note = "{\textcopyright} The Author(s) 2018.",

year = "2018",

month = jun,

day = "7",

doi = "DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-26100-5",

language = "English",

volume = "8",

journal = "Scientific Reports",

issn = "2045-2322",

publisher = "Springer",

number = "8717",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Radiologists can detect the ‘gist’ of breast cancer before any overt signs of cancer appear

AU - Brennan, Patrick

AU - Gandomkar, Ziba

AU - Ekpo, Ernest

AU - Tapia, Kriscia

AU - Trieu, Phuong

AU - Lewis, Sarah

AU - Wolfe, Jeremy

AU - Evans, Karla

PY - 2018/6/7

Y1 - 2018/6/7

N2 - Radiologists can detect abnormality in mammograms at above-chance levels after a momentary glimpse of an image. The study investigated this instantaneous perception of an abnormality, known as a “gist” response, when 23 radiologists viewed prior mammograms of women that were reported as normal, but later diagnosed with breast cancer at subsequent screening. Five categories of cases were included: current cancer-containing mammograms, current mammograms of the normal breast contralateral to the cancer, prior mammograms of normal cases, prior mammograms with visible cancer signs in a breast from women who were initially reported as normal, but later diagnosed with breast cancer at subsequent screening in the same breast, and prior mammograms without any visible cancer signs from women labelled as initially normal but subsequently diagnosed with cancer. Our findings suggest that readers can distinguish patients who were diagnosed with cancer, from individuals without breast cancer (normal category), at above-chance levels based on a half-second glimpse of the mammogram even before any lesion becomes visible on the mammogram. Although 20 of the 23 radiologists demonstrated this ability, radiologists’ abilities for perceiving the gist of the abnormal varied between the readers and appeared to be linked to expertise. These results could have implications for identifying women of higher than average risk of a future malignancy event, thus impacting upon tailored screening strategies.

AB - Radiologists can detect abnormality in mammograms at above-chance levels after a momentary glimpse of an image. The study investigated this instantaneous perception of an abnormality, known as a “gist” response, when 23 radiologists viewed prior mammograms of women that were reported as normal, but later diagnosed with breast cancer at subsequent screening. Five categories of cases were included: current cancer-containing mammograms, current mammograms of the normal breast contralateral to the cancer, prior mammograms of normal cases, prior mammograms with visible cancer signs in a breast from women who were initially reported as normal, but later diagnosed with breast cancer at subsequent screening in the same breast, and prior mammograms without any visible cancer signs from women labelled as initially normal but subsequently diagnosed with cancer. Our findings suggest that readers can distinguish patients who were diagnosed with cancer, from individuals without breast cancer (normal category), at above-chance levels based on a half-second glimpse of the mammogram even before any lesion becomes visible on the mammogram. Although 20 of the 23 radiologists demonstrated this ability, radiologists’ abilities for perceiving the gist of the abnormal varied between the readers and appeared to be linked to expertise. These results could have implications for identifying women of higher than average risk of a future malignancy event, thus impacting upon tailored screening strategies.

U2 - DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-26100-5

DO - DOI:10.1038/s41598-018-26100-5

M3 - Article

VL - 8

JO - Scientific Reports

JF - Scientific Reports

SN - 2045-2322

IS - 8717

M1 - 8717

ER -