Repertoires of paedophilia: Conflicting descriptions of adult-child sexual relationships in the investigative interview

TY - JOUR

T1 - Repertoires of paedophilia

T2 - Conflicting descriptions of adult-child sexual relationships in the investigative interview

AU - Benneworth, Kelly

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - A review of the literature revealed that adult-child sexual relationships are often described in terms of personal bonds and emotions in pro-paedophile propaganda and the accounts of convicted paedophiles. On the other hand, in the investigative interview police officers must encourage offenders to be precise in their accounts and describe sexual contact. Research has not determined whether these two conflicting approaches to the description of paedophilia are observable in police interviews and, if so, considered the implications for the criminal investigation. Eleven audiotaped police interviews with paedophiles conducted at a Child Protection Unit in 2000 were transcribed. A corpus of 20 'physical' references to sexual activity and bodily contact and 42 'emotional' words involving feelings and relationships were identified and the incidence of the terms was quantified. Content analysis confirmed that police officers and paedophiles do describe adult-child sexual relationships differently in the investigative interview. The police used the 'physical' repertoire more frequently, while the suspects exhibited a preference for the 'emotional' repertoire (x(2) =125.518; df =1; p < 0.01). The suspects also used euphemistic and colloquial language more frequently than the police (X-2= 65.964; df = 1; p < 0.01). The practical implications of the study and recommendations for future research are outlined.

AB - A review of the literature revealed that adult-child sexual relationships are often described in terms of personal bonds and emotions in pro-paedophile propaganda and the accounts of convicted paedophiles. On the other hand, in the investigative interview police officers must encourage offenders to be precise in their accounts and describe sexual contact. Research has not determined whether these two conflicting approaches to the description of paedophilia are observable in police interviews and, if so, considered the implications for the criminal investigation. Eleven audiotaped police interviews with paedophiles conducted at a Child Protection Unit in 2000 were transcribed. A corpus of 20 'physical' references to sexual activity and bodily contact and 42 'emotional' words involving feelings and relationships were identified and the incidence of the terms was quantified. Content analysis confirmed that police officers and paedophiles do describe adult-child sexual relationships differently in the investigative interview. The police used the 'physical' repertoire more frequently, while the suspects exhibited a preference for the 'emotional' repertoire (x(2) =125.518; df =1; p < 0.01). The suspects also used euphemistic and colloquial language more frequently than the police (X-2= 65.964; df = 1; p < 0.01). The practical implications of the study and recommendations for future research are outlined.

KW - Content analysis

KW - Suspected paedophile

KW - Repertoire

KW - Discourse

KW - Police

KW - Investigative interview

U2 - 10.1558/ijsll.2006.13.2.189

DO - 10.1558/ijsll.2006.13.2.189

M3 - Article

SN - 1748-8885

VL - 13

SP - 189

EP - 211

JO - International Journal of Speech, Language and the Law

JF - International Journal of Speech, Language and the Law

IS - 2

ER -