The importance of deliberation in valuing ecosystem services in developing countries-Evidence from the Solomon Islands

Jasper O. Kenter; Tony Hyde; Michael Christie; Ioan Fazey

doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2011.01.001

The importance of deliberation in valuing ecosystem services in developing countries-Evidence from the Solomon Islands

Jasper O. Kenter^*, Tony Hyde, Michael Christie, Ioan Fazey

^*Corresponding author for this work

Environment and Geography

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

Abstract

Monetary valuation of ecosystem services enables more accurate accounting of the environmental costs and benefits of policies, but this has rarely been applied in developing countries. In such contexts, there are particular methodological and epistemological challenges that require novel valuation methodologies. This paper introduces a new participatory, deliberative choice experiment approach conducted in the Solomon Islands. The research aimed to determine the value people placed on ecosystem services and whether participatory interventions to elicit deeper held values influenced the preferences expressed. Results found that the initial willingness to pay for a number of tropical forest ecosystem services amounted to 30% of household income. Following deliberative intervention exercises, key ecosystem services effectively became priceless as participants were unwilling to trade them off in the choice experiment scenarios, regardless of financial cost. The group based deliberative approach, combined with participatory interventions, also resulted in significant learning for participants. This included a more sophisticated view of ecological-cultural linkages, greater recognition of deeper held values, and greater awareness of the consequences of human actions for the environment. The use of a group-based participatory approach instead of a conventional individual survey helped to overcome many of the practical difficulties associated with valuation in developing countries. Given the impact of learning on valuation outcomes, participation and deliberation should be integrated into valuation of any complex good, both in developing and developed economies. However, such a methodology raises questions about how valuation can deal with unwillingness to trade-off key ecosystem services, which results in the breakdown of monetary valuation methods. Evaluation of the appropriateness of valuation processes and methodologies for assessing deeper held values and use of mixed-method approaches will be essential to ensure policies take into account the extent to which human life is dependent on ecosystem services.

Original language	English
Pages (from-to)	505-521
Number of pages	17
Journal	Global Environmental Change
Volume	21
Issue number	2
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2011.01.001
Publication status	Published - 1 May 2011

Keywords

Deliberative valuation
Developing countries
Ecosystem services
Environmental values
Participatory approaches
Social choice experiments
Solomon Islands

Access to Document

10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2011.01.001

Cite this

@article{4d0890ee55974272bce84cc8e134418a,

title = "The importance of deliberation in valuing ecosystem services in developing countries-Evidence from the Solomon Islands",

abstract = "Monetary valuation of ecosystem services enables more accurate accounting of the environmental costs and benefits of policies, but this has rarely been applied in developing countries. In such contexts, there are particular methodological and epistemological challenges that require novel valuation methodologies. This paper introduces a new participatory, deliberative choice experiment approach conducted in the Solomon Islands. The research aimed to determine the value people placed on ecosystem services and whether participatory interventions to elicit deeper held values influenced the preferences expressed. Results found that the initial willingness to pay for a number of tropical forest ecosystem services amounted to 30% of household income. Following deliberative intervention exercises, key ecosystem services effectively became priceless as participants were unwilling to trade them off in the choice experiment scenarios, regardless of financial cost. The group based deliberative approach, combined with participatory interventions, also resulted in significant learning for participants. This included a more sophisticated view of ecological-cultural linkages, greater recognition of deeper held values, and greater awareness of the consequences of human actions for the environment. The use of a group-based participatory approach instead of a conventional individual survey helped to overcome many of the practical difficulties associated with valuation in developing countries. Given the impact of learning on valuation outcomes, participation and deliberation should be integrated into valuation of any complex good, both in developing and developed economies. However, such a methodology raises questions about how valuation can deal with unwillingness to trade-off key ecosystem services, which results in the breakdown of monetary valuation methods. Evaluation of the appropriateness of valuation processes and methodologies for assessing deeper held values and use of mixed-method approaches will be essential to ensure policies take into account the extent to which human life is dependent on ecosystem services.",

keywords = "Deliberative valuation, Developing countries, Ecosystem services, Environmental values, Participatory approaches, Social choice experiments, Solomon Islands",

author = "Kenter, {Jasper O.} and Tony Hyde and Michael Christie and Ioan Fazey",

year = "2011",

month = may,

day = "1",

doi = "10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2011.01.001",

language = "English",

volume = "21",

pages = "505--521",

journal = "Global Environmental Change",

issn = "0959-3780",

publisher = "Elsevier",

number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The importance of deliberation in valuing ecosystem services in developing countries-Evidence from the Solomon Islands

AU - Kenter, Jasper O.

AU - Hyde, Tony

AU - Christie, Michael

AU - Fazey, Ioan

PY - 2011/5/1

Y1 - 2011/5/1

N2 - Monetary valuation of ecosystem services enables more accurate accounting of the environmental costs and benefits of policies, but this has rarely been applied in developing countries. In such contexts, there are particular methodological and epistemological challenges that require novel valuation methodologies. This paper introduces a new participatory, deliberative choice experiment approach conducted in the Solomon Islands. The research aimed to determine the value people placed on ecosystem services and whether participatory interventions to elicit deeper held values influenced the preferences expressed. Results found that the initial willingness to pay for a number of tropical forest ecosystem services amounted to 30% of household income. Following deliberative intervention exercises, key ecosystem services effectively became priceless as participants were unwilling to trade them off in the choice experiment scenarios, regardless of financial cost. The group based deliberative approach, combined with participatory interventions, also resulted in significant learning for participants. This included a more sophisticated view of ecological-cultural linkages, greater recognition of deeper held values, and greater awareness of the consequences of human actions for the environment. The use of a group-based participatory approach instead of a conventional individual survey helped to overcome many of the practical difficulties associated with valuation in developing countries. Given the impact of learning on valuation outcomes, participation and deliberation should be integrated into valuation of any complex good, both in developing and developed economies. However, such a methodology raises questions about how valuation can deal with unwillingness to trade-off key ecosystem services, which results in the breakdown of monetary valuation methods. Evaluation of the appropriateness of valuation processes and methodologies for assessing deeper held values and use of mixed-method approaches will be essential to ensure policies take into account the extent to which human life is dependent on ecosystem services.

AB - Monetary valuation of ecosystem services enables more accurate accounting of the environmental costs and benefits of policies, but this has rarely been applied in developing countries. In such contexts, there are particular methodological and epistemological challenges that require novel valuation methodologies. This paper introduces a new participatory, deliberative choice experiment approach conducted in the Solomon Islands. The research aimed to determine the value people placed on ecosystem services and whether participatory interventions to elicit deeper held values influenced the preferences expressed. Results found that the initial willingness to pay for a number of tropical forest ecosystem services amounted to 30% of household income. Following deliberative intervention exercises, key ecosystem services effectively became priceless as participants were unwilling to trade them off in the choice experiment scenarios, regardless of financial cost. The group based deliberative approach, combined with participatory interventions, also resulted in significant learning for participants. This included a more sophisticated view of ecological-cultural linkages, greater recognition of deeper held values, and greater awareness of the consequences of human actions for the environment. The use of a group-based participatory approach instead of a conventional individual survey helped to overcome many of the practical difficulties associated with valuation in developing countries. Given the impact of learning on valuation outcomes, participation and deliberation should be integrated into valuation of any complex good, both in developing and developed economies. However, such a methodology raises questions about how valuation can deal with unwillingness to trade-off key ecosystem services, which results in the breakdown of monetary valuation methods. Evaluation of the appropriateness of valuation processes and methodologies for assessing deeper held values and use of mixed-method approaches will be essential to ensure policies take into account the extent to which human life is dependent on ecosystem services.

KW - Deliberative valuation

KW - Developing countries

KW - Ecosystem services

KW - Environmental values

KW - Participatory approaches

KW - Social choice experiments

KW - Solomon Islands

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79956257396&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2011.01.001

DO - 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2011.01.001

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:79956257396

SN - 0959-3780

VL - 21

SP - 505

EP - 521

JO - Global Environmental Change

JF - Global Environmental Change

IS - 2

ER -

The importance of deliberation in valuing ecosystem services in developing countries-Evidence from the Solomon Islands

Abstract

Keywords

Access to Document

Other files and links

Cite this