Thinking about the Past and Experiencing the Past

Dorothea Debus

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

Abstract

The present article aims to show that a subject can only fully grasp the concept of the past if she has some experiential, or recollective, memories of particular past events. More specifically, I argue that (1) in order for a subject to understand the concept of the past, it is necessary that the subject understand the concept of a particular past event in such a way that it might contribute to her understanding of the concept of the past. (2) But then, in order for a subject to understand the concept of a particular past event in such a way that it might contribute to her understanding of the concept of the past, it is necessary that the subject have some recollective memories of particular past events. (C) Hence, a subject can only understand the concept of the past if she has some recollective memories of particular past events. I defend the premises of the present argument against various objections, indicate why we should accept both premises, and accordingly end by endorsing the argument's conclusion.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)20-54
Number of pages35
JournalMind and Language
Volume28
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2013

Cite this